AGGREGATED ASSAULT!

Free Metal E-Mail









New Users Sign Up

Connect. Befriend. Follow.

Share |



Other swag here
metal rules swag



Van Canto
Tribe of Force
March 2010
Released: 2010, Napalm Records
Rating: 3.5/5
Reviewer: Alan Gilkeson

When they released their first album independently back in 2006 the general consensus was overwhelmingly positive, Van Canto had generated a very interesting record, flowing with vocal talents, great vocal melodies, and almost operatic power. However, there remained just a tinge of gimmick, and a lingering question of whether their a capella brand of Metal could contend with their guitar wielding peers. TRIBE OF FORCE, their third long player, stays the course, more Power Metal sans the Power, and has the band still knocking on the door of legitimacy, but doing nothing to open it.



The best, and most successful aspect of Van Canto is their translation of traditional instrumentalized metal into a capella form, or cover songs. After three albums, most of Van Canto's original work remains as it began, a bit bland and boring, save for the occasional captivating tune, usually with the female vocal in the lead, like 'Water. Fire. Heaven. Earth.' on this disc, but even then the instrumental sounds and 'guitar' solo come off a bit silly. Easily, the two most entertaining tunes on the album are both covers, 'Master of Puppets' and Grave Digger's 'Rebellion' which features Chris Boltendahl singing the lead. The a capella thing works with the cover songs, it's just more engaging to hear the works we know done this way. The originals sort of bleed into one another.



Without intending insult, Van Canto are a bit of a gimmick, albeit a very accomplished one. What they do is very unique and entertaining, but still it is outside of the realm of serious Metal. The live experience of Van Canto is probably quite incredible, and I look forward to the day they make it to North America, but to make a bad comparison, they're sort of like Gwar, a band that's not really attractive for their original studio work, but rather the live setting and use of a gimmick. For my money, Van Canto should do all cover songs. They'd sell more and draw more. Still, it's hard to give them a bad score...
Track Listing

1. Lost Forever (4:40)
2. To Sing a Metal Song (3:24)
3. One to Ten (feat. Victor Smolski) (4:06)
4. I Am Human (3:56)
5. My Voice (5:30)
6. Rebellion (Grave Digger Cover - feat. Chris Boltendahl) (4:05)
7. Last Night of the Kings (3:52)
8. Tribe of Force (3:17)
9. Water. Fire. Heaven. Earth. (3:32)
10. Master of Puppets (Metallica cover) (8:23)
11. Magic Taborea (3:22)
12. Hearted (feat. Tony Kakko) (4:00)
13. Frodo's Dream (3:06)

Lineup

Philip Dennis "Sly" Schunke - Lead Vocals (Synasthasia)
Inga Scharf - Lead Vocals (Fading Starlight)
Stefan Schmidt - Lower "Rakkatakka" Vocals, "Wahwah" Solo Guitar Vocals
Ross Thompson - Higher "Rakkatakka" Vocals
Ingo "Ike" Sterzinger - Lowest "Dandan" Voice Chords ((cp))
Bastian Emig - Drums

Other reviews

» A Storm To Come
by EvilG

» Tribe of Force
by Alan Gilkeson


Next review: » Van Deventer, Jay - Banzai Records Companion Issue #1 (Book review)
Previous review: » Van Canto - A Storm To Come





Home | About Metal-Rules.com | Staff | Advertise With Us | Staff Openings | Donations

Content is © 2009-2012 Metal-Rules.com. All Rights Reserved.
Graphics by Hammerblaze studio.